Civil Litigation In Texas
Texas Civil Litigation in State District Court — Contract & Business Disputes Overview
Pre-Suit Considerations
Before filing, a party typically evaluates:
Is there a valid claim? Texas recognizes breach of contract, fraud, tortious interference, breach of fiduciary duty, and related business torts.
Statute of limitations: Most contract claims have a 4-year limitations period in Texas (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 16.004). Fraud is also 4 years. Written contracts tied to specific shorter terms may vary.
Contractual prerequisites: Many contracts require a formal written demand, mediation, or notice before suit. Skipping these can be fatal to a claim.
Demand letters: Not legally required in most cases, but commonly sent to create a record, trigger a contractual notice period, or prompt settlement.
Venue: A suit must be filed in a proper county — generally where the defendant resides, where the contract was to be performed, or where the events occurred (Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 15.001 et seq.).
Filing the Lawsuit
Original Petition: The plaintiff files an Original Petition with the district clerk. Texas uses "notice pleading" — the petition must give fair notice of the claims and relief sought, but doesn't need exhaustive detail.
Rule 47 Statement: The petition must include a statement of the monetary range of damages sought (e.g., over $250,000 but not more than $1,000,000). This affects court assignment and jury fees.
Filing fees vary by county and damages range, typically several hundred dollars.
Case assignment: The case is assigned to a specific district court (many urban counties have specialized business courts or dockets).
Note: Texas now has a dedicated Business Court (launched 2024) for certain large commercial disputes, which is a separate track from general district courts.
Service of Process
The defendant must be formally served with the citation and petition, typically by a process server or constable.
A defendant has 20 days plus the following Monday to file a written answer after service.
If a defendant is evading service, the court may authorize alternative methods (posting, publication, etc.).
Defendant's Answer & Initial Motions
The defendant files an Original Answer, which usually consists of a general denial (denying all allegations) — Texas permits this broad denial as a starting point.
The defendant may also file:
Special exceptions (challenging the sufficiency of the petition)
Verified denials (required to contest specific facts like capacity, payment, or forgery)
Affirmative defenses (waiver, estoppel, limitations, failure of consideration, etc.)
Counterclaims or third-party claims
A Motion to Transfer Venue must be filed before any other plea or it is waived.
Discovery
Texas follows the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure (TRCP). Discovery is the most time-consuming phase in most business disputes.
Discovery levels (Rule 190):
Level 1 — Simpler cases, limited discovery
Level 2 — Default; discovery period runs from the earlier of 30 days after the first request or 6 months after filing, through 30 days before trial
Level 3 — Court-ordered custom plan for complex cases
Discovery tools include:
Requests for Disclosure — Standard background info (witnesses, legal theories, damages)
Interrogatories — Written questions (capped at 25 under Level 2)
Requests for Production — Documents, ESI (electronically stored information), contracts, emails
Requests for Admission — Admit or deny specific facts
Depositions — Oral testimony under oath; can depose opposing parties and third-party witnesses
Discovery disputes are resolved by motion — a party can file a Motion to Compel if the other side fails to respond, or a Motion for Protective Order to limit overreaching discovery.
Case Management & Deadlines
The court will typically issue a Scheduling Order (or "Docket Control Order") setting deadlines for:
Expert designations and reports
Discovery cutoff
Dispositive motion deadlines
Trial date
Expert witnesses are common in business disputes (damages experts, industry experts, accountants). Failure to properly designate experts on time can result in exclusion.
Dispositive Motions
Before trial, either party may seek to end the case (or narrow the issues) through:
Traditional Motion for Summary Judgment (MSJ): Argues there is no genuine issue of material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
No-Evidence MSJ: After adequate time for discovery, argues the non-movant has no evidence on one or more essential elements of a claim or defense. The burden then shifts to the non-movant to produce some evidence.
These are heavily used in Texas business litigation and can resolve cases without trial.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Texas courts strongly encourage or require mediation before trial.
Many scheduling orders include a mandatory mediation deadline.
Parties select a private mediator; the mediator is neutral and facilitates settlement but cannot impose a result.
Arbitration may be required if the underlying contract contains an arbitration clause — in that case, the court litigation may be stayed and the dispute sent to a private arbitrator.
Trial
If the case doesn't settle, it proceeds to trial.
Jury vs. bench trial: Either party may demand a jury (must be requested and fee paid in advance). Business contract cases often involve juries, though parties can agree to a bench trial.
Jury selection (voir dire): Attorneys question potential jurors; strikes for cause and peremptory strikes narrow the panel to 12 (district court).
Trial sequence: Opening statements → Plaintiff's case-in-chief → Defendant's case → Rebuttals → Closing arguments → Jury charge and deliberation.
Jury charge: Critically important in Texas. The judge submits questions to the jury ("Did the defendant fail to comply with the contract? What sum of money would fairly compensate the plaintiff?"). Texas uses a broad-form submission approach.
Damages: May include actual/compensatory damages, consequential damages, attorneys' fees (commonly available in contract cases under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 38.001), and sometimes exemplary (punitive) damages if fraud or malice is proven.
Post-Trial Motions
After verdict, the losing party may file:
Motion for New Trial — Must be filed within 30 days of judgment; required to preserve many appellate issues.
Motion to Modify, Correct, or Reform the Judgment
Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict (JNOV)
Appeal
Appeals from district court go to the Texas Court of Appeals (14 intermediate appellate courts organized by region).
Notice of appeal must be filed within 30 days of judgment (or 90 days if a Motion for New Trial was filed).
Appeals are based on the written record — no new evidence. Briefing, oral argument (sometimes), and a written opinion follow.
Further review may be sought at the Texas Supreme Court, which has discretionary jurisdiction over civil cases.
Post-Judgment Enforcement
Winning a judgment is only the beginning if the defendant doesn't pay voluntarily:
Abstract of Judgment — Filed with the county clerk; creates a lien on the debtor's real property in that county.
Writ of Execution — Directs the sheriff/constable to seize non-exempt property.
Writ of Garnishment — Targets bank accounts or money owed to the debtor by third parties.
Post-judgment discovery — Plaintiff can conduct discovery to locate assets.
Texas homestead and exemption laws are very debtor-friendly and can significantly limit what is collectible.
Let’s discuss your options.
Contact us today to set up a free consultation.
